Legendary Baits

"Handmade Soft Plastics"

About Us

At Legendary Baits, fishing isn’t just a pastime—it’s a way of life. Proudly serving Shipshewana and the surrounding communities, we specialize in expertly crafted handmade baits designed to attract even the most elusive catch. Whether you're chasing trophy bass or enjoying a peaceful day on the water, our gear is built for performance and reliability.

Our shop offers a full selection of live bait, premium fishing rods—including custom builds and ice fishing options—along with tackle essentials and accessories to elevate every angling experience. From first-time fishermen to seasoned pros, Legendary Baits is your trusted source for quality gear and genuine passion for the sport.

Our Story

Legendary Baits – Shipshewana’s Premier Fishing Shop

At Legendary Baits, fishing is more than a hobby—it’s a way of life. Founded by a local angler who turned a personal struggle into a passion, Legendary Baits began as a way to stay focused and productive while recovering from addiction. Through dedication, patience, and a love for the outdoors, what started as a small craft of handmade soft plastics has grown into a trusted fishing shop serving Shipshewana, Indiana, and the surrounding areas. Our story is one of resilience, craftsmanship, and a genuine commitment to helping anglers enjoy the sport to its fullest.

The heart of Legendary Baits is its owner, whose personal journey shaped the shop’s philosophy: quality, reliability, and a deep respect for the fishing community. Every product, from handmade baits to rods and accessories, reflects the owner’s dedication to crafting gear that works in real fishing conditions. Legendary Baits is proud to support anglers of all levels, from beginners just discovering the joy of fishing to seasoned pros chasing trophy catches.

Located just 2 miles south of SR 120, Legendary Baits has become a staple in the local fishing community. Anglers appreciate the personal touch, expert advice, and hands-on guidance that comes with every visit. The shop’s welcoming environment encourages customers to explore, learn, and find the right gear for their next adventure. Legendary Baits isn’t just a place to buy fishing products—it’s a place to connect with a passionate angler who understands what it takes to make every fishing trip a success.

What sets Legendary Baits apart is the combination of craftsmanship, knowledge, and genuine care for the local fishing community. The owner personally tests and refines every product, ensuring that each bait, rod, and accessory meets high standards of quality and performance. This dedication has earned Legendary Baits a loyal following of customers who trust the shop for reliable fishing gear and expert guidance.

At Legendary Baits, we believe fishing is about more than catching fish—it’s about creating memories, enjoying the outdoors, and sharing a passion with friends and family. Our mission is to provide tools and advice that enhance every outing, making it easier for anglers to enjoy their time on the water. By focusing on quality, local service, and personal experience, Legendary Baits has become a trusted destination for anglers across Shipshewana and nearby communities.

Whether you’re a lifelong fisherman or new to the sport, Legendary Baits is dedicated to helping you make every trip memorable. With a story rooted in perseverance, a shop built for the local angler, and a commitment to excellence, Legendary Baits embodies what it means to be part of the fishing community. Visit us today and discover why Legendary Baits is more than a shop—it’s where passion, experience, and quality come together to create legendary fishing experiences.

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Handmade Bait

Our Services include:

Live Bait - Legendary Baits offers a premium selection of live bait that is carefully sourced and maintained to ensure peak freshness and effectiveness. Whether you're targeting bass, panfish, or other freshwater species, our live bait options—including red wigglers, wax worms, night crawlers and other proven favorites—are ideal for anglers who value traditional methods and reliable results. We understand that live bait can make the difference between a slow day and a successful outing, which is why we prioritize quality and consistency in every batch.
Fishing Rods - Our fishing rods are crafted to meet the demands of both recreational and serious anglers. Designed for balance, sensitivity, and durability, these rods provide excellent control and responsiveness across a variety of fishing conditions. Whether you're casting from shore, trolling from a boat, or exploring local streams, our rods are built to deliver performance and comfort. Each rod is selected for its ability to handle the rigors of freshwater fishing while maintaining the finesse needed to land elusive catches. Spinning and casting rods available!
Ice Fishing Rods - Built specifically for cold-weather angling, our ice fishing rods are compact, rugged, and highly sensitive. These rods are engineered to perform in freezing temperatures, allowing anglers to detect subtle bites beneath the ice. With ergonomic grips and sturdy construction, they offer both comfort and reliability during long hours on the ice. Whether you're targeting perch, walleye, or trout, our ice rods are designed to help you fish with precision and confidence in even the harshest winter conditions.
Tackles - Legendary Baits provides a comprehensive selection of tackles that includes hooks, sinkers, swivels, leaders, and more. Each item is chosen for its quality and effectiveness, ensuring that anglers have the right tools for any fishing scenario. Our tackle inventory supports a wide range of techniques, from finesse fishing to power casting, and is suitable for both beginners and seasoned pros. We believe that dependable tackle is the foundation of a successful fishing setup, and we stock only gear that meets our high standards.
Fishing Accessories - Our fishing accessories are designed to enhance every aspect of your angling experience. From tackle boxes and bait buckets to line cutters and rod holders, we offer practical tools that make your time on the water more efficient and enjoyable. These accessories are selected for their durability, ease of use, and compatibility with various fishing styles. Whether you're organizing gear, preparing bait, or managing your catch, our accessories help streamline your process and keep your focus on the fish.
Custom Fishing Rods - Legendary Baits specializes in handcrafted custom fishing rods tailored to your exact specifications. These rods are built with precision and care, allowing you to choose the length, action, grip style, and finish that best suit your fishing preferences. Our custom rods combine aesthetic appeal with high-performance functionality, making them a favorite among anglers who demand both style and substance. Each rod is a reflection of our commitment to craftsmanship and our passion for helping you land that legendary catch.

Our Brands include:

Flueger
Lews
Abu Garcia
MHX
CRB
HT
Ugly Stick
Vexilar
Strikemaster
Tungsten

Our Products include:

Live Bait
Lures
Fishing Rods
Ice Fishing Rods
Tackles
Fishing Accessories
Custom Fishing Rods
Fishing Rod Covers

Testimonials

On 9/30/2026 Keith Hochstetler had this to say:
7'6" med-hvy mod fast Mhx crank bait rod from shallow to deep diver cranks this rod amazed me how it preforms definitely recommend it

On 4/23/2026 Zachary Bontrager had this to say:
Definitely recommend this place!I thinks it’s the best bait shop around!!! A big fan of the 2” grub,fluke and the curly tail! You’ll definitely catch some crappie with these.

On 4/17/2026 Anthony Bontrager had this to say:
Bought a rod and love it

On 11/4/2025 Mike Y. had this to say:
Awesome customer service. Love the baits. They last a good while longer than most and work better than most. Testimonial written by Mike Y. on this site.

On 6/20/2025 Kevin Miller had this to say:
His baits are truly legendary. One of my favorite baits is his solid body tube. I have caught numerous 5+ pound small mouth with them, including my 6.76 pound PB . Give his baits a try you won’t be disappointed Testimonial written by Kevin Miller on this site.

Contact Us

Legendary Baits
3992 N 675 W Shipshewana, IN 46565
Phone: (260) 336-8089
Fax: (260) 977-9203
Email: aaronhoch2000@gmail.com

Located 2 miles south of SR 120

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Personal Checks, Credit Cards, Debit Cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay

Our Hours

Monday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Thursday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM - 1:00 PM

News

🎣 Fresh Live Bait. Proven Results.
When it comes to freshwater fishing, the right live bait can make all the difference. Legendary Baits offers a premium selection of live bait that is carefully sourced and maintained to ensure freshness, quality, and effectiveness.

From red wigglers and wax worms to night crawlers and other angler favorites, we have the live bait you need to help attract more bites and improve your time on the water.

✅ Fresh, quality bait
✅ Ideal for bass, panfish, and more
✅ Consistently maintained for peak performance

Stop by and stock up before your next fishing trip!

🌐 https://legendarybaits.com/

#LegendaryBaits #LiveBait #FishingLife #FreshwaterFishing #NightCrawlers #WaxWorms #RedWigglers #FishingGear

Whether you're fishing from the shoreline, trolling from a boat, or exploring your favorite freshwater stream, Legendary Baits offers fishing rods designed to deliver the performance anglers demand.

Our spinning and casting rods provide the ideal combination of balance, sensitivity, and durability, helping you detect subtle strikes and maintain control when it matters most.

✅ Comfortable handling
✅ Responsive performance
✅ Built for freshwater fishing
✅ Spinning & casting rods available

Find the right rod for your next adventure and fish with confidence.

🌐 https://legendarybaits.com/

#LegendaryBaits #FishingRods #SpinningRod #CastingRod #FishingGear #FreshwaterFishing #AnglerLife

The right accessories can make all the difference on the water. At Legendary Baits, we offer durable fishing accessories designed to help you stay prepared and focused on what matters most, catching fish.
From tackle boxes and bait buckets to rod holders and line cutters, our accessories are built for convenience, reliability, and compatibility with a variety of fishing styles.

✅ Durable construction
✅ Easy to use
✅ Designed for anglers of all experience levels

Upgrade your fishing setup with accessories that work as hard as you do.

🌐 https://legendarybaits.com/

#LegendaryBaits #FishingAccessories #FishingGear #AnglerLife #FishingTools #OutdoorAdventure #FishingEquipment

🎣✨ Custom Rods Built for Your Perfect Catch ✨🎣
At Legendary Baits, we know every angler has their own style—and your gear should match it. That’s why we offer custom fishing rod services designed to fit your exact needs, whether you're out chasing trophy fish or enjoying a quiet day on the lake.
Our handcrafted rods are built with precision, quality materials, and a passion for performance, giving you the control, comfort, and reliability you need every time you cast. From ice fishing setups to all-season rods, we’ll help you create something truly one-of-a-kind.
Stop in and let us build a rod that’s as legendary as your next catch. 🎣
#LegendaryBaits #CustomFishingRod #FishingLife #AnglerGear #Shipshewana #BuiltForTheCatch

The bite is hot, the days are long, and your tackle box should be stacked! This summer, save money when you buy soft plastic baits in bulk from Legendary Baits. Whether you’re gearing up for tournaments, guiding trips, or nonstop weekend runs to the water, bulk orders mean more baits, more casts, and more catches—without breaking the bank.
Our soft plastics are crafted to perform when the fish are fired up, and ordering in bulk keeps you ready for every strike all season long. Stock up once and fish hard all summer! 🌊🔥
👉 Save more. Fish more. Catch more.
📍 3992 N 675 W, Shipshewana, IN 46565
📩 Questions or bulk inquiries? Reach out through our website or give us a call—we’re happy to help get you dialed in.
https://legendarybaits.com
📞(260) 336-8089

Info

Product List

FAQ

What types of live bait does Legendary Baits offer?

We provide a premium selection of live bait including red wigglers, wax worms, night crawlers and other proven favorites. In wintertime we also carry spikes. All bait is carefully sourced and maintained to ensure freshness and effectiveness for targeting bass, panfish, and other freshwater species.

Do you sell custom fishing rods?

Yes! We specialize in handcrafted custom fishing rods tailored to your exact specifications. You can choose the length, action, grip style, and finish to match your fishing style. Each rod is built for performance and aesthetic appeal.

Are your fishing rods suitable for beginners?

Absolutely. Our fishing rods are designed for both seasoned anglers and beginners. They offer excellent balance, sensitivity, and durability, making them easy to use while providing the control needed for successful fishing.

What makes your ice fishing rods different?

Our ice fishing rods are built specifically for cold-weather conditions. They’re compact, rugged, and highly sensitive—perfect for detecting subtle bites under the ice. With ergonomic grips and sturdy construction, they’re ideal for long hours on frozen lakes.

What fishing accessories do you carry?

We offer a wide range of fishing accessories including tackle boxes, bait buckets, line cutters, rod holders, and more. Each item is selected for durability and ease of use to help make your fishing trips more efficient and enjoyable.

Site Navigation